SurveyGizmo vs. LimeSurvey

We recently automated surveys at my employer. For many years we sent word documents out to our membership, who would edit them and either email or fax them back to us. With the current economy some positions were eliminated, including the person who did all of this survey work. This meant the time for automation was at hand, but how?

The first choice is a survey system that would be integrated into our other business systems. However this is a complex undertaking and will take some time to develop. In the mean time I still needed something that would get the job done.

After much searching, I settled on SurveyGizmo and Limesurvey. Both have similar features, but in the end I chose SurveyGizmo mainly because it was hosted, which avoided additional load on our IT staff. Limesurvey is open source, is web-based, and runs on Apache/PHP/MySQL. We don’t have any servers able to provide this environment, so running Limesurvey entailed extra complexity.

I have spent quite a bit of time in SurveyGizmo, and while I’m mostly happy with my choice there are a few things that anyone else in the similar position should consider:

Email invitations don’t do any good unless they reach their recipient. The first thing I learned about SurveyGizmo is that our email filters blocked their emails. We can unblock them for us, but what about our members? With this observation in mind I contacted SG to find out what could be done to ensure emails would get through. Their solution is to create an SPF record for our domain that would authorize their servers as senders of email on our behalf, but there are reasons why this isn’t such a peachy idea.

The invitations sent from Limesurvey didn’t have trouble getting through.

We actually send the invitations through a different system in practice, so it is less of an issue for us but that means losing a lot of neat functionality for doing reminders and tracking response.

With Limesurvey you have direct database access to the data, and this is awesome if you use the data to create custom reports, time series across many surveys, or combinations of survey results. SurveyGizmo doesn’t allow this, and their data import is strictly in cross-tab format. That is, multiple columns for each question. This works if you don’t intend to put the data into a database, but really, really sucks if you do. I’m working around it with a series of Excel macros to convert the data, but I don’t want to do this long term. SurveyGizmo has quoted providing the data in a different format, but the fees involved exceed those for an integrated survey system. Not a reasonable choice!

The ability to enter a survey on behalf of an invitee – say one of the people who just loves to fax the results in – is much easier with Limesurvey. In SG you have to download the entire list of invitees to get the survey link, paste that into a browser, and then take the survey. Not a huge deal, but it could be a factor if you have a lot of manual returns.

It’s not all bad though.

SurveyGizmo has phone support, a much nicer interface, much clearer documentation, and snazzier question styles. Ranking, in particular, is spiffy with little up/down arrows for each choice.

Piping survey questions or pages of questions from a single question, which allows parts to be repeated multiple times depending on previous answers, is easy to understand and implement.

Pages, which are analogous to groups in Limesurvey, are automatically defined which eliminates a layer of complexity.

Changing question order is drag & drop – even between pages.In Lime it’s more laborious.

Overall I would probably choose SurveyGizmo again, in my current situation. If I had more time, and if we had other sites running on Apache/PHP/MySQL Limesurvey would be more attractive. We run mainly repeats of a given set of surveys. If we did more one-off kind of surveys, I think SurveyGizmo’s better interface/design environment would carry more weight.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s